When Law & Economics Violates the Rule of Law: Three Illustrations
GAICIL Insights
Law & Economics and the Rule of Law share theoretical roots, yet the article shows that they collide in three places: the Coase theorem, the theory of efficient breach of contract, and the rule of reason in competition law.
The point matters for any field where efficiency analysis drives enforcement. Rules for AI markets will need both economic rigor and the predictability the Rule of Law requires.
Abstract
Law & Economics scholarship movement continues to be an important methodological approach to the positive and normative analysis of law since its inception in the second half of the 20th century. However, Law & Economics has been criticized on various grounds, from its over-reliance on consequentialist arguments against deontological arguments to its indifference towards the fundamental concepts of law such as the Rule of Law. This latter argument is scrutinized and further illustrated in this article. Here, we demonstrate that despite the common theoretical underpinnings between Law & Economics and the Rule of Law (I), it is argued that Law & Economics conflicts with the Rule of Law principles on three major instances, namely the Coase theorem, the theory of efficient breach of contracts and the influential rule of reason in the field of competition law and policies (II). We therefore conclude that there cannot be a practical convergence between Law & Economics and the Rule of Law at the universal level unless Law & Economics revisits some of its normative conclusions that conflict with the Rule of Law as exemplified in this article.1
Takeaway
“There cannot be a practical convergence between Law & Economics and the Rule of Law at the universal level unless Law & Economics revisits some of its normative conclusions that conflict with the Rule of Law.”
Quoted verbatim from the author’s abstract.
Notes
- Aurelien Portuese, When Law & Economics Violates the Rule of Law: Three Illustrations, 2018 Rule of L. & Anti-Corruption Ctr. J. art. 5 (2018), https://doi.org/10.5339/rolacc.2018.5. Abstract quoted verbatim from the publisher’s abstract record, https://doi.org/10.5339/rolacc.2018.5. ↩
Cite as: Aurelien Portuese, When Law & Economics Violates the Rule of Law: Three Illustrations, 2018 Rule of L. & Anti-Corruption Ctr. J. art. 5 (2018), https://doi.org/10.5339/rolacc.2018.5
Header image: Doha - West Bay Skyline 04.jpg by P. Hughes, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
